5 (Scary Easy) Halloween Party Recipes


Evolving from the ancient Celtic holiday of Samhain, modern Halloween has become less about literal ghosts and ghouls and more about costumes and candy. The Celts used the day to mark the end of the harvest season and the beginning of winter, and also believed that this transition between the seasons was a bridge to the world of the dead.  Over the millennia the holiday transitioned from a somber pagan ritual to a day of merriment, costumes, parades and sweet treats for children and adults.

5 (Scary Easy) Halloween Party Recipes

  • Halloween Party Recipes

The amount of Halloween party recipes and ideas floating around the Internet is impressive. I want to celebrate the season and have fun like everyone else, but let’s get real. In my opinion, the kitchen is the scariest place in my home. Yikes!

I generally try to keep my culinary adventures easy peasy. Or, I’ll try a recipe once I’ve heard from a few or like 10 people, that it’s really easy. Case in point, I’ve never regretted attempting these slow cooker tacos, but it took a lot of convincing. Eh, but tacos don’t really scream, “Halloween.” I want to try a recipe that is both scary easy and fun.

I’ve compiled a list of Halloween-inspired recipes – featuring dairy, of course! – that I think are less scary and more fun. To help me judge these factors, I’m using the Motion Pictures Association of America’s rating system (to rate scariness) and the typical academic grading scale (to rate the fun factor).My list of 5 (scary easy) Halloween party recipes:

“Spooky Ghost Milkshakes”

Dairy: Milk and frozen yogurt , https://www.midwestdairy.com/retailers/recipes/

Banana Caramel Smoothie (yummie)    Banana caramel smoothie in a glass with a red straw.

We guarantee you’ll go bananas over this scrumptious smoothie with a decadent mix of milk, bananas and caramel sauce.
Prep Time5 mins
Total Time5 mins
Servings: 3 servings


Calories: 155kcal


  • 2 medium bananas peeled and sliced
  • 2 cups fat-free milk
  • ¼ cup caramel sauce


  • Combine all ingredients in a blender; blend until smooth. Serve in tall glasses or on-the-go drink containers.


Use frozen banana slices to chill and thicken your smoothie. Just peel and slice each banana and freeze in a separate zip-top plastic bag. This is a great way to use ripe bananas and have them ready for your next smoothie.

Scary Rating: I can’t complain about the simple ingredients list, and the preparation is minimal.  YUMMY

Ghost Milkshakes Recipe

Fun Factor: I like how you can customize the glasses to your level of spooky, but I don’t think this recipe would be too much fun as a solo project. The fun rating would go up when making it with little ghosts and goblins. A-

Guacamole with Black Olive Spiders

Dairy: Greek yogurt

Scary Rating: The ingredients list is longer, but individually, the ingredients are simple. Minimal scary factor at the grocery store. PG

Halloween Guacamole Recipe
Image source: Florida dairy farmers

Fun Factor: What a presentation! The salsa cob web makes it special, and hands down, I love black olives. Plus, this recipe comes from my Florida dairy farmer friends too. A+

Pumpkin Cheese Ball

Dairy: Cheddar and cream cheese

Scary Rating: The Food Network calls this recipe easy, and I tend to agree. The cheese ball needs at least two hours to chill so plan

Pumpkin Cheese Ball
Image source: Food Network

ahead to maximize this non-scary recipe. I wouldn’t use the minced jalapenos it calls for; another reason this recipe seems pretty easy. GFun Factor: Crushing tortilla chips, or pretty much anything crunchy into bits, is usually pretty fun. The presentation looks nice, plus you get 2 hours for more fun while the cheese ball chills. A

Pillsbury Mummy Dogs

Dairy: Cheese

Scary Rating: You can’t be a perfectionist with these mummy dogs. The dough may not cover correctly or the mustard eyes could get lop-sided. This is the

Image source: Food Network

recipe where you just have to go for it, and hope it all works out. Ease any fears and watch video with Pillsbury’s recipe. PGFun Factor: I grew up with “pigs in a blanket” so the fun factor for me is the nostalgia of turning these hot dogs into mummies. A

Mummy Spinach Dip

Dairy: Mozzarella string cheese, Parmesan cheese and sour cream

Scary Rating: This recipe no doubt requires an investment of time. The ingredients list and instructions are lengthy. PG-13

Image source: SnackWorks.com

Fun Factor: I’m definitely drawn to the creativity. The string cheese mummy bandages and black olive eyes (I really like black olives) – this recipe was made to be enjoyed at a party. A+Do you have a scary easy Halloween recipe I should try? Share in the comments. And, best wishes for a safe and enjoyable Halloween!


Posted On October 9th, 2014 by   (Found this on-line and credit is given)…
Categorized as Recipes

By Marie Moody

Married to my Soulmate. Mother of 4, grandmother of 12, and great-grandmother of 2 and owner of 1 demanding black lab & I'm a retired Legal Assistant & pianist. I am also on disability due to Spinal Stenosis. I am now a blogger which I love very much & it keeps me busy & I also enjoy crocheting.

1 comment

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.